377Views 7Comments
Pakistan Navy Marines’ 21st Air Defence Battalion assigned to Ormara
On Friday, July 14 the Pakistan Navy held a ground-breaking ceremony for the Pakistan Navy Marines 21st Air Defence Battalion in Ormara, Baluchistan.
The 21st Air Defence Battalion was established in 2005 as part of the Navy’s effort to provide air defence coverage to all national infrastructure along Pakistan’s coasts, such as shipyards and deep-sea ports.
In its official press release, Inter Services Public Relations (ISPR) stated that the “battalion is equipped with state-of-the-art air defence guns, surface-to-air missiles and air defence radars.”
Notes & Comments:
In 2012 the Navy’s Marines branch was shown using several low-altitude air defence systems, namely twin 35-mm towed anti-air guns (AAG) – either Chinese Type-90s or Swiss Oerlikons – linked to Skyguard fire-control radars (FCR). It also used man portable air defence systems (MANPADS).
The Pakistan Ministry of Defence Production’s (MoDP) yearbook for 2014-2015 lists the procurement of six Skyguard FCRs, one SkyGuard simulator, 12 35-mm AAGs and 500 infrared surface-to-air missile (SAM) units (likely MANPADS). It appears that at least some of these were allocated to the Marines.
The Skyguard radar has a maximum range of 20 km. In response to aerial threats, the radar controller can set the linked 35-mm AAGs to fire at the target up to a range of 3,000 to 4,000 m. MANPADS, such as the Anza, Mistral and RBS-70 Mk2, can engage at ranges of 5,000 m, 6,000m and 8,000 m, respectively.
It is evident that the Marines’ air defence capacity is tailored for neutralizing low-flying threats, which can be a factor considering the reality that Pakistan has adjoining coastlines with Iran and India.
The Chief of Naval Staff Admiral Muhammad Zakaullah stated that air defence development was “a clear priority” for the naval leadership, especially for Coastal Command. However, it is unclear if efforts will be laid for longer range air surveillance radars and SAMs.
In June 2016, the Pakistan Navy leadership had requested information from South Africa about the Denel Dynamics Umkhonto SAM system. Utilizing a terminal-stage imaging infrared seeker with mid-course (via data-link) guidance system, the Umkhonto has a range of 20 km. Denel Dynamics’ upcoming Umkhonto EIR variant will have a range of 30-35 km. The Umkhonto is available as a ground-based air defence system and as an anti-air warfare (AAW) module for surface warships equipped with vertical-launch system (VLS).
According to Denel Group’s 2016 annual report, Denel announced that it was undertaking a $61.36 million U.S. contract to supply and integrate Umkhonto SAMs onto two Algerian MEKO A-200AN frigates (each ship is equipped with 32 VLS cells). Assuming one Umkhonto battery can include four eight-cell launchers, a per-battery cost of $30 million could be within Pakistan’s fiscal reach. Pakistan spent $62.2 million and €41.5 million per HQ-16 and Spada-2000-Plus battery, respectively. The Saab Giraffe AMB radar (which is used by Algeria’s MEKO frigates) cost the Philippines $12.5 million per radar (Saab has also partnered with Denel to integrate the Giraffe AMB to the Umkhonto).
Theoretically, the Umkhonto platform could provide the PN with a relatively affordable SAM system that it can station on land and fit as an AAW solution on its warships, such as the F-22P and MILGEM (assuming it is designed to have space for VLS cells – like the LF-2400). Longer-range and higher altitude threats have generally been managed by the Pakistan Air Force, but the Army’s HQ-16 acquisition shows that the other service arms can assume greater ownership of their AAW requirements. It is not known if the PN still intends to pursue the Umkhonto – or medium-range SAMs in general – for its air defence requirements.
7 Comments
by ali amanat
Bilal sir, is there any indigenous development programme of SAM systems from low to high altitude , please shed some light , with ever changing security scenario in our region especially after indian acquisition of air defence systems from the America and israel , Paf is going to share more burden , so a local and indigenous SAM system is more important.
by Steve
This is good news and a good start. In any future conflict, however limited, PAF will have its hands full with fending off the IAF with its larger numbers and arguably more sophisticated aircraft. There may not be enough capacity to also protect critical infrastructure. IAF are going to try intense attacks for a limited period and then stop, and get America/Europe/Russia to stop Pakistan as well and declare ‘victory’, followed by widespread celebrations, Western countries giving ambivalent duplicitous statements, and Modi getting reelected. The PAF used to think that for air defence, fighters are best. I think they are changing that philosophy and need to induct an integrated layered system with something like HQ-9 for long range for all services, assuming we can’t get S-400 for political and finance reasons. I don’t see the point of having Erieye with 450 km coverage and not be able to reach into India that far with SAM or aircraft, even if we fly Erieye inland to avoid their SAM and aircraft. A lot of their bases are a lot less than 450 km from the border, and we will see and should be able to engage aircraft taking off from Pathankot so to speak. We need to deter a jingoistic adventure by Doval/Modi et al and if we don’t succeed then prevent a declaration of victory which be difficult if they lose 20 aircraft.
by reader
Bilal. Your analysis in your articles is very high quality ! keep it up
by ahmria
Pakistan should look to get a multilayered capability in SAMs to protect critical infrastructure. Long range system like the S400 which with the associated missiles would also cover intermediate range and then Pantsir S1 for short to medium range and point defence cover. This protection wouldn’t come cheap but could Pakistan afford to allow infrastructure to be repeatedly attacked? Shorad system like manpads have their uses but are useless against high altitude attacks or high speed saturation attacks.
by ali amanat
Very true to give PAF free hand to handle IAF.
by Ali Afzal
Well navy can induct FM-90 SAM system & can buy Korkut Air Defense Gun system from Turkey. It’s still unclear if the Army has inducted LY-80 SAM system or is it Air Force.
by Steve
I think we all agree that the time has come for Pakistan to have a long range SAM system. Let’s see if the army also see it.